Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: NFL Roundtable: Which Draft Pick Is Most Likely To Bust?

Curious Case of the High Stick

No.. not the 5 different high sticking penalties that were called last night - that was just a bit of sloppy hockey from some tired players.  I'm talking about Dan Fritsche's alleged high stick that resulted in the Wild getting a goal to tie up the game in the second period. 

The guys over at Fifth Feather said this:

Judd Sirott had a sound bite from NHL war room veteran Mike Murphy who indicated there was no conclusive evidence it was a high stick saying one replay showed the tip was legit and the other may have been a high stick but the camera was at a bad angle.  Alas, that wasn’t the last break that wouldn’t go the ‘Hawks way.

Now I haven't actually heard Sirott's sound bite but if it's true one has to wonder - why the hell don't they have a better camera angle?  From the angle that was shown on Comcast - it seemed pretty clear that Fritsche's stick was well above the crossbar when it made contact with the puck.  Even the Wild fan who joined us for the Game Thread thought we got the shaft on that one. 

The angle that we all saw was the camera directly behind the net which is positioned a little above the crossbar which obviously makes it harder to determine the right angles of the play.  So why not put cameras dead even with the cross bars on each side of the rink? 

The posts on an NHL goal are 4 feet high but the boards on the ice are anywhere between 40"-48" so the max they can be is 4 feet as well (though the NHL says 42" is "ideal"). That would leave plenty of room both behind the net and along the sides of the ice to put cameras to better capture what happens.

If the NHL insists on having a war room in Toronto looking over everything (and I still don't know if that would be an awesome job or a horrible one) then why don't they do everything they can to ensure they have the best possible angles to view the action?

Wild_goal_medium

I refuse to believe a small camera couldn't be placed near the X (and three others on the other corners obviously) to get the best view of the play in front of the net without obstructing the view of those sitting along the boards (because you know those rich bastards would complain).

This isn't the first time a goal like this has been controversial... so why not put cameras in the right place to see the crossbars and where a player's stick is - no one else in this game kept thier stick down so why should we believe Fritsche did?

I'm not complaining too much about this game because Harding was obviously a bigger factor in this game than that goal - and it would have almost been a shame for him to have played so well and still lost but I could have gotten over that pretty easily.

Also, have the Refs ever come out of a review and said "the replays were inconclusive - therefore the call on the ice stands"?

Comment 11 comments  |  0 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

More from Second City Hockey

Comments

Display:

Probably should have also added that

the guy said since the replays were inconclusive, they back the call made by the refs on the ice. The camera behind the net was deemed to be looking down at the action due to the position of the cameraman thus inconclusive. No doubt the NHL should look into this, a goal shouldn’t be allowed/disallowed because a cameraman is taller than the goalposts.

FifthFeather.com

by El Duque's Raft on Feb 23, 2009 1:36 PM CST reply actions  

And since the goalposts are all 4 feet high – I think the NHL should only hire midgets to be cameramen

by Killion on Feb 23, 2009 1:42 PM CST up reply actions  

Hey now

Little people, Chicagokill, little people!

Secondly, I do believe that little people + hockey has already been attempted through The Love Guru, to failure, at best.

http://www.blackhawkey.com (in development!)

by SeabrookAnd7Up on Feb 23, 2009 2:24 PM CST reply actions  

I am confused about the over-the-net camera

Was it it off-center? During the review of if the puck went over the line, why is the view not DIRECTLY down so the crossbar lines up with the redline of the goal? It is a few inches off, and thus throwing off an exact angle.

by JoeCoolMan24 on Feb 23, 2009 3:30 PM CST reply actions  

Howard Johnson is Right!

I agree completely. But since you bring up little people, couldn’t we have some sort of intermission show like midget bowling but maybe Midget Curling instead?

by Gbubbs on Feb 23, 2009 8:02 PM CST reply actions  

You'd think with the technology these days

They could figure out exactly where the puck is at any given time – I mean, they used to do that Fox sports “glowing puck” abomination.

White Sox: Trying to roll a hard six.

by vince_ on Feb 24, 2009 11:28 AM CST reply actions  

Agreed

This is the first time the Wild have gotten a break from the powers that be in Toronto. There needs to be a better angle that allows them to see the level of the stick. I mean, they have a camera over the goal line, why can’t they get one to conclusively tell the height of a stick?

by nathaneide on Feb 24, 2009 10:10 PM CST reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

SBN's source for all things Chicago Blackhawks. Online home of The Committed Indian. Please don't take this place seriously.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recommended FanPosts

Goalie_small
Blackhawks Goaltenders- A Photographic History
0327092sham1_small
SCH INLINE HOCKEY CLUB: SUNDAY, May 20 at NOON!

Recent FanPosts

18667_287486396686_6459871686_3580584_5338204_n_small
Who is tradeable on the roster or in the system to fill needs right now.
Small
OT: What type of jersey do you have?
Hpim1632_small
SCH Inline Hockey Game Sunday May 6th @ Noon
334rules_avatar_small
Slightly down, no place close to out.
Zuul_small
Fels, McClure, Kills, Hack and the rest of the SCH crew.
Iancurtis_small
Pack Up the Hawks
Goalie_small
Random Goaltending Knowledge of the Day- Goalie Skates
Marlins-logo-new_small
How Long Should Torres Be Out?

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >


Triumvirate of Stupid

Photo_11_small Killion

34548_409975644603_503814603_4258799_6800286_n_small SamFels

Chicago_flag_small McClure

Actual Intelligence

Airstaff_waddle250_small Hack

Morning Links

Blch_small chelischili7

Pogo_small JuliaM

Moderator

Vertical_hold_2_small Skags

H121125a_small SKeen

Pandaeatingraffi_small ahnfire

Cartman_hawk2_small stacie7